AI Strategy

Is digital marketing still worth it in 2026?

Half of what you pay for every month is rent. The other half is a page you own, and it keeps answering after the money stops.

By Carol Roderick, PhD  ·  October 22, 2026 AI Strategy AI Visibility

Yes. Digital marketing still works in 2026, and it has two parts. One you own and pay for once. One you keep paying for.

The phone went quiet and nothing looks broken. The page is still up. It still ranks. The chart tilts down a little more every month.

That's when you start hearing that digital marketing is over.

It isn't.

A property is something you own. A house, even with a mortgage on it. You're still paying every month, and at the end of the day you keep it. Even in this market, I'd rather own than rent.

A page on your own site is property. You wrote it once and it answered somebody's question at eleven last night while you slept. It'll answer it again next week for somebody else.

Running an ad is rent. You pay, the ad runs, the month ends, and you're paying again next month to keep the same ad in front of people. The visit was real. The placement is the part you don't keep.

I know which of those two I'd rather have working for me.

Pew Research Center followed 900 American adults through 68,879 Google searches in March 2025 and measured what's happening to your clicks.

You've seen it yourself. You type a question into Google and the answer is already sitting there above the links, before you get to click anything.

I do it too. I get the answer, I don't make the visit, and I'm happy about it. That's worth admitting when I'm the one who wrote the page.

When that answer appears, people click a regular result 8 percent of the time. When it isn't there, 15 percent. The summary cuts that person's chance of visiting your site by half.

Then Pew counted the links inside the summary, the short source list under the answer. People followed one of those 1 percent of the time. Most readers read the answer and stopped.

Length matters too. Type one or two words into Google and a summary shows up 8 percent of the time. Type ten words or more and it shows up 53 percent of the time. People stopped typing keywords, and they write the whole question out the way they'd ask it across a counter. Google answers it on the page instead of connecting them to your site.

That was March 2025, and a year is a long time in this. It's gone further since, not back. SparkToro read Similarweb click data for US Google searches from January through April 2026 and found 68.01 percent of them ended with no click at all, against 60.45 percent in 2024.

People are still looking for answers, but now they get the answers before they get to your site.

The rented half is paid media. Ads, sponsored posts, the placement you buy at a price that resets every month. The rent comes due whether the month was good or quiet. Ring a bell?

I use it. Renting attention puts your name in front of strangers this week. A page you own can't do that until somebody goes looking for you.

The IAB raised its US ad spend forecast for 2026 to 12.3 percent growth in September. In January it had said 9.5 percent. The money isn't leaving.

It's moving. When the IAB asked buyers where they were putting more effort, the top answer was content built to show up in AI answers. Twenty-six percent said they were putting less weight on their own site traffic.

Most owners are already paying for a website that says very little, and nobody ever told them a page is supposed to answer one question. I've never seen it taught. So the page talks about the business instead, and the buyer leaves to find the answer somewhere else.

You don't have to rewrite all of it. Start with the handful of pages that already bring buyers in, give each one a single question to answer, and make it the plainest answer to that question anywhere.

A summary about your subject carries your name or it carries a competitor's, and those are two different jobs. Being cited and named isn't the same work as ranking.

That's what the AI Visibility Check is for. It looks at which of your pages AI engines read in your field, and whether your name comes back when somebody asks about your subject.

If you're the business and the business is you, your marketing time is the hour left over after the work. Spend it renting and the month ends empty. Spend it on a few pages that answer real questions and you own something that outlives the month.

Nothing else about the work changes, and the page keeps answering while you're doing something else entirely.

Frequently asked questions

Does an organic page still work if nobody clicks it?

Yes. An AI engine reads it and repeats what it says. We need to stop treating clicks as the only proof our pages are working.

Should I still pay for ads?

Yes, for now. Paid ads buy a call this month, and US ad spend is up again in the IAB's September update. They're the part of the budget that renews, so they need a fresh reason every month.

Do I need to rewrite my whole website?

No. The pages that already bring buyers in are the cheapest attention you'll get. Give each one a single question to answer and leave the rest alone.

Sources

Pew Research Center, "Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears in the results", 22 July 2025. pewresearch.org

Rand Fishkin, "In 2026, Less than One Third of Google Searches Still Send a Click", SparkToro, 8 June 2026, using Similarweb clickstream data for January to April 2026. sparktoro.com

IAB, "2026 Outlook Study: September Update", 10 September 2026. iab.com


Carol Roderick holds a PhD in Education from the University of New Brunswick and works as an AI adoption consultant and implementation partner at carolroderick.ca. She works with professionals whose expertise is the product, building AI systems that run inside the business rather than beside it.